You need certified translation whenever the destination wants a complete English translation plus a signed statement from the translator or provider confirming accuracy. USCIS is the clearest example because the regulation and multiple current USCIS evidence checklists talk about complete English translation and translator certification. That is why certified vs notarized translation usually ends quickly for immigration filings: for most USCIS packets, the certified part is the actual requirement and the notarized part is optional unless some other destination adds it.
The same logic applies to many schools, credential evaluators, employers, and state agencies. If the receiving authority is mainly concerned with understanding the contents of a foreign-language document, certified translation is usually the relevant standard. A diploma, transcript, birth certificate, or marriage certificate does not become more informative because a notary watched someone sign a statement. It becomes more usable because the translation is complete, accurate, and easy to trust. That is why /documents/diploma and /documents/marriage-certificate workflows center on translation quality first.
In practice, certified translation is often enough when the instructions mention "certified translation," "complete English translation," "translator certification," or similar wording. It is also usually the safer default when the instruction says nothing about notarization. If you are still unsure, run the document set through the /tools/requirements-checker before ordering. That is faster than paying for a notarization add-on that the destination never asked for in the first place.